Here’s a quirky detail: they both use “Carr” with two ‘r’s. That’s not the standard spelling of the name. It’s a deliberate choice by both families, but for completely unrelated reasons.
Jimmy was born James Anthony Carr. The extra ‘r’ was already there. Alan’s real surname is just Carr, but he’s never changed it. Pure coincidence, not a secret pact.
Some fans think the double ‘r’ is a secret handshake. It’s not. It’s just a funny quirk that fuels the rumor mill even more.
Jimmy Carr talks Funny Business as he heads for Liverpool - Liverpool Echo
What Do The Carrs Think?
Alan Carr has addressed this directly. He once said, “People always ask if I’m related to Jimmy. I say, ‘No, but I wish I was—imagine the Christmas presents!’” He plays along with the joke.
Jimmy, ever the deadpan master, once quipped: “Alan is my brother. We just don’t share parents.” He loves the confusion. It’s a free comedy bit for both of them.
They’ve never denied it with anger. They lean into the absurdity. That’s what makes this topic so fun—it’s a silly mystery with a simple answer.
